Independent stationery reviews · 100 products on the shelf · Updated October 2026

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Pencils & Colored Pencils

Palomino Blackwing 602 Pencil

by Palomino Blackwing

8.8

Quill Pier score

  • Core9.1
  • Feel8.4
  • Build8.8
  • Value8.9

The Palomino Blackwing 602 remains a benchmark in premium pencils, prized for its firm, smooth graphite and refined cedar body.

  • Smooth firm graphite
  • Premium cedar body
  • Replaceable eraser design

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

what you get

Key features

  1. 01Firm graphite core (balanced hardness, between HB and 2H)
  2. 02Hexagonal-to-rounded cedar barrel with signature flat ferrule
  3. 03Replaceable white eraser held by flat clip-style ferrule
  4. 04Metallic gold foil stamping with 602 model number
  5. 05Sold in boxes of 12 pencils
  6. 06California incense-cedar construction for smooth sharpening

the honest bit

Pros & cons

What we liked

  • Smooth, firm graphite ideal for writing and fine linework
  • Premium cedar wood sharpens cleanly with minimal splintering
  • Elegant matte pearl-grey finish feels luxurious in hand
  • Replaceable eraser extends usable life of each pencil
  • Iconic design appreciated by writers, artists, and collectors alike

What could be better

  • Higher price point than standard graphite pencils
  • Eraser performance is mediocre compared to separate erasers
  • Firmer lead may feel scratchy to those preferring softer graphite
  • Flat ferrule can catch on pencil cup edges or bags

from our desk

Our Palomino Blackwing 602 Pencil review

The Palomino Blackwing 602 pencil stands as one of the most storied instruments in the world of fine stationery, a faithful revival of the legendary Eberhard Faber pencil once favored by novelists, animators, and composers throughout the twentieth century. Its slender, cedar-cased body is finished in a muted pearl gray with gold foil stamping that reads "Half the Pressure, Twice the Speed," a nod to the original marketing slogan that made the pencil famous among creative professionals. The signature flat, replaceable eraser sits snugly in a ferrule at the end, held in place by a small golden clasp, giving the pencil an unmistakable silhouette that distinguishes it instantly from ordinary round or hexagonal pencils found in typical stationery drawers.

What truly sets the Blackwing 602 apart is its graphite core, engineered to be firm yet smooth, striking a balance that appeals to those who want precision without sacrificing glide across the page. Writers who favor extended journaling sessions, architects sketching fine lines, and planners who demand crisp, legible notes all find the medium-soft lead accommodating to a variety of pressures and styles. The cedar wood itself is sustainably sourced and sharpens to a clean, splinter-free point, releasing a faint, pleasant aroma reminiscent of classic pencil cases and old desks, which adds a sensory richness to the simple act of writing or sketching in a planner.

As a staple within the Stationery & Planners category, the Blackwing 602 is often chosen not just for its performance but for the ritual and identity it brings to daily writing practices. Many planner enthusiasts keep one on hand specifically for annotating calendars, marking important dates, or jotting quick reflections in the margins of a notebook, appreciating how the pencil's weight and balance make extended use comfortable. Packaged typically in sets of twelve within a minimalist box that echoes the pencil's vintage aesthetic, the Blackwing 602 has become a quiet symbol of craftsmanship for those who believe that even the smallest tools in a planner setup deserve thoughtful design and lasting quality.

how it stacks up

Compared with top pencils

ProductBest atCoreFeelBuildQP scoreOpen
Palomino Blackwing 602 PencilThis reviewSmooth firm graphite9.18.48.88.8
Faber-Castell Polychromos Colored PencilsFaber-CastellLightfast archival pigments9.49.89.19.8
STAEDTLER Noris Colored PencilsStaedtlerBreak-resistant lead8.78.78.99.0
Tombow Mono Drawing PencilsTombowSmooth consistent graphite9.28.49.49.0

The verdict

Our verdict

The Palomino Blackwing 602 remains a benchmark in premium pencils, prized for its firm, smooth graphite and refined cedar body. While the eraser underperforms and the price sits above typical pencils, its writing feel, aesthetics, and legacy make it a staple for writers, artists, and planner enthusiasts who want a dependable, elevated everyday tool.

8.8
Palomino Blackwing 602 PencilQuill Pier score 8.8 / 10
Check price